The story’s score and claims

Comments on No. 12 of 60 · Dor Cohen · edition of Monday 16 November 2026

No Free Lunch, No Free Rollback: Where Agents Need Engineers

Summary

Dor Cohen argues that the No Free Lunch theorem doesn't show AI will always need engineers, but that the cost of a mistake does shape where they stay necessary. Where changes can't be undone, as when a PocketOS agent deleted a production database volume, trial and error isn't available. Where they can, someone still has to judge each attempt. Supporting data: asking clarifying questions lifted Claude 4.5 Sonnet from 54.8% to 69.4% on SWE-bench Verified. The thesis is a conceptual sketch, not tested.

Comments

Ranked by a public rubric, not by votes: what a comment adds counts, not who wrote it. How comments are ranked · Comment rules